I wouldn't even bother to attempt to settle it for 1 cent. Just ignore them and do not talk to them. They will get the message eventually.
As I stated a few times in this forum, collection agencies constantly dig up prehistoric debts like the one you have and try their luck to see if they can get anything out of it. The fact is that the creditor gave up their right to sue you within 2 years from the date of last activity and it was their decision. This debt does not show up in your credit report nor it is retrievable through legal actions. Just be fiscally responsible and do not make the same mistake again.

