by footloose » Sat Jan 22, 2011 02:48:10 PM
@duckyduckerson
Well.......I must have made a wrong assumption. I was not aware that you were a licensed lawyer practicing in Ontario and very familiar with with the Rules of Practice and Procedure in both the Small Claims Court and the Superior Court of Justice. You're just the man we need on this website to answer all these legal questions that are asked by our members and readers.
Now lets see. For starters, could you provide the name of the Act or Statute including date passed, date it became law, Section, Subsection, Paragraph, etc. that provides the authority for the Small Claims Court in Ontario to award punitive damages? Or, to put it another way, please provide the name of the Act or Statute, complete with supporting documentation, which provides the Small Claims Court in Ontario the jurisdiction to hear any case brought before the court seeking either punitive or exemplary damages. As a practicing lawyer, this should be easy for you. Funny thing. When I was in law school, my professors never mentioned this. I wonder what I am missing?
Regarding the case that you mentioned in Saskatchewan, that occurred in October, 2005 i.e. Leslie Kenneth Neil v. Equifax Canada Inc. That case was highlighted on this website by the founder, Monty Loree. Unfortunately, he made the same mistake that you did. He only chose to read what he wanted to read. What he failed to tell the members and readers of this website was that while Leslie Kenneth Neal was initially awarded punitive and exemplary damages of $4,500 by the Saskatchewan Provincial Court, Equifax appealed this decision to the Saskatchewan Court of Queen's Bench where it was OVERTURNED in April, 2006. Why wasn't this case reported on this website? If you are an informed lawyer, you would have read this case and have been very familar with the decision. My experience with competent lawyers is that they don't do a "half-assed" job.
In another blog by Monty Loree, he indicated that consumers would now be able to sue both Equifax and TransUnion in Ontario Small Claims Court. I requested documentation to support his claim but he chose not to respond. Up until now, neither he, nor anyone else has responded to my request. Maybe, you're the guy.
Also, in your blog, you say "LOTS of people have sued Iqor, Iqor always settles out". Maybe it's me, but I am not aware of just ONE case where Iqor has been sued either successfully or settled out of court. Apparently, you are quite an expert in this area so it should be very easy for you to quote a particular case in which Iqor was the defendant. Please provide the name of the Plaintiff, the date the case was filed, in which court, the results of the court case and the damages awarded to the Plaintiff.
I will be anxiously waiting for your replies. If you can't, then PUT UP OR SHUT UP.